Property Investment News, Strategies, Tools and Opinions

Most buyer's agents won't show you their misses. Ask for them before you sign.

Written by Jake Milne | 3 Nov 2026, 2:51:00 am

By Jake Milne, CEO & Lead Buyers Agent, MOGL | MOGL.com.au

Every buyer's agent will show you their wins. Very few will show you the purchases that went backwards. So how do you check the one you're about to trust with the biggest purchase you'll make?

A bad buyer's agent rarely gives advice that sounds bad. They quietly steer you toward what pays them, or use a suburb method that sounds clever and doesn't hold up over ten years. You won't see the damage until the houses nearby have grown and yours hasn't.

Here are six checks, in the order I'd run them. The first takes five minutes.

1. Is the licence real?

A buyer's agent must hold a current real estate licence, or work under one, in the state where they're buying. The rules differ by state. A licence in Victoria doesn't cover a purchase in Queensland.

Ask for the licence number for each state they buy in, then look it up on that state's public register. The NSW Government guide shows how it works there. A polished website proves nothing.

A licence tells you they're allowed to operate. It doesn't tell you who they work for.

2. Who else is paying them?

Some agents take payments from developers for steering clients into new builds or off-the-plan apartments. That payment shapes what lands on your shortlist.

Ask these four questions and expect straight answers:

  • Do you receive any payment, commission or referral fee from a developer, a seller or anyone else?
  • Do you recommend new builds or off-the-plan apartments? Why?
  • Are you tied to a developer, a project marketer or a mortgage broker?
  • Will you put all of that in writing in the agreement?

A vague answer is an answer. Then look at how they charge you.

3. Does the fee reward them for spending more of your money?

Fees come in three types: a fixed fee, a percentage of the purchase price, or a mix. A percentage fee is usually 1.5% to 2.5%. It's common and it's open, but it does mean the agent earns more when you pay more.

A fixed fee stays the same whatever you pay for the house. Whichever type it is, get every part of it in writing before you sign: what's covered, when it's due, and what happens if your brief changes. We charge a fixed flat fee and take nothing from anyone else.

Now for the check that sorts the serious operators from the good marketers.

4. Can they explain how they pick a suburb?

Two houses at the same price in the same city can end up a long way apart after ten years. The suburb does most of that.

Ask: how do you choose where to buy? A real answer is built on things you can check:

  • Population growth
  • Jobs and infrastructure spending
  • Vacancy and rental demand
  • How many new homes are coming
  • Past growth against similar suburbs

"Experience" and "a strong local network" don't count as a method.

5. Will they show you every result?

Awards and media spots are nice. They aren't proof. A track record is: what was bought, for how much, and what it's worth now.

Most buyer's agents don't publish theirs. When you ask, look for:

  • Real purchase prices next to current values
  • Growth over years, not one good 12 months
  • The purchases that underperformed
  • Enough purchases to judge a method, not a few lucky picks

We publish every client purchase on our results page, including the ones that went backwards. I'd rather you see those before you call me than after.

6. Do they model the bad years?

"Data driven" gets thrown around a lot. Ask what's behind the numbers. Honest modelling starts with higher interest rates and lower growth than today.

Walk away if you see:

  • Growth forecasts with no time frame or caveats
  • Returns pumped up by borrowing to make the headline bigger
  • Suburbs picked on a short price spike
  • No mention of what could go wrong
  • Pressure to hurry

If an agent only shows you the best case, they're selling.

Do you even need one?

Not everyone does, mate. If you know your market well, have time to inspect widely and can negotiate, you might manage on your own. A buyer's agent earns the fee when you're buying interstate, buying your first investment, or short on time to do the research properly.

A record you can only see the good half of isn't a record.

Run these checks on us

If you want to test a buyer's agent against this list, start with us. Look through the results, then book a free 15-minute discovery call and ask me anything on it.

Book a free 15-minute discovery call

Jake Milne | CEO & Lead Buyers Agent, MOGL
MOGL.com.au | jake@mogl.com.au

This article is general in nature and does not constitute licensed real estate, financial or credit advice. Talk to your broker and accountant before making any investment decision.