MOGL insights

Your buyer's agent checks the house. Who checks the buyer's agent?

Magnifying glass on an inspection checklist with red ticks, beside a model house

By Jake Milne, CEO & Lead Buyers Agent, MOGL | MOGL.com.au

You hire a buyer's agent to do the checking for you. The industry has grown fast, and the checking varies a lot. So who checks the buyer's agent?

You do. Here are seven steps to run before you sign anything. Each one comes with a question to ask.

1. Check the licence

A buyer's agent must hold a real estate licence, or work under one, in the state where the property is. Look them up on the state register yourself. In NSW you can check through NSW Fair Trading.

Membership of REBAA or PIPA is voluntary, and a good extra sign. If an agent won't share a licence number, note it.

Ask: "What's your licence number in the state I'm buying in?"

2. Ask how they choose a suburb

You want a set method built on numbers you can check: how many homes are for sale against how many buyers, rents, recent sales, who's moving in, and what's being built.

If the answer is "everyone's buying there" or "it's a hotspot", be careful. Good data doesn't guarantee a result. A decision made without it is a guess.

Ask: "Show me the data and the rules you used to pick this suburb."

3. Ask what could go wrong

Any agent can tell you what could go right. The good ones also model what could go wrong: higher rates, lower growth, weeks with no tenant, flood zones, too many new homes nearby.

If they only show you the best case, they're selling.

Ask: "Can I see a sample report before I sign?"

4. Ask why this market and not another

The suburb you buy in usually matters more than the house. An agent who only buys in one area may never tell you that a different market suits your budget better. An agent who buys anywhere needs someone on the ground to avoid a bad house in a good suburb.

You want both: a national comparison, then a local check.

Ask: "Which other markets did you compare this one with?"

5. Ask them to walk you through the process

They should be able to lay out every stage, from your brief to settlement:

  • A strategy session on your budget, borrowing power and comfort with risk
  • A suburb shortlist with written reasons
  • Property screening
  • Inspections in person
  • Building, pest, flood and strata checks
  • A negotiation plan
  • Settlement, with your conveyancer and broker

If they can't explain it clearly, they probably haven't built it. For each client we assess up to 10 properties on risk, cash flow and expected growth before we present a shortlist.

Ask: "How many properties do you rule out for each one you recommend?"

6. Ask for every result

This is the step most investors skip. Ask for the full record: dates, locations, prices, growth, and the ones that underperformed. Testimonials only tell you someone was happy.

We publish every client purchase on our results page, including the ones that went backwards. If an agent won't share theirs, ask yourself why.

Ask: "Show me a purchase that didn't work, and what you learned."

7. Ask who pays them

An independent buyer's agent is paid by you and nobody else. No developer, builder or selling agent.

Then look at the fee. A fixed flat fee is the same whatever you spend. With a percentage fee, the agent earns more when you pay more for the house. We charge a fixed flat fee. Get any fee in writing before you sign.

Ask: "Do you receive any payment or referral fee from anyone other than me?"

One thing no agent can promise

Nobody can guarantee what the market will do. I can't either. Be careful with anyone who says they can. What an agent can give you is a clear process, careful numbers and a record you can check. We back our service with a written guarantee in the service agreement. Ask me how it works and where its limits are.

An agent who welcomes these questions has usually done the work.

Run these seven steps on us

Start with the results page. Then book a free 15-minute discovery call and put every one of these questions to me.

Book a free 15-minute discovery call

Jake Milne | CEO & Lead Buyers Agent, MOGL
MOGL.com.au | jake@mogl.com.au

This article is general in nature and does not constitute licensed real estate, financial or credit advice. Talk to your broker and accountant before making any investment decision.

/* Make body a flex column so we can reorder children */ body { display: flex; flex-direction: column; min-height: 100vh; } /* The body-wrapper contains header + main + global footer */ .body-wrapper { display: flex; flex-direction: column; flex: 1; } /* Move the global theme footer to the very end */ .body-wrapper > footer, .body-wrapper > .footer { order: 99; margin-top: auto; } /* Blog CTA and manifesto sections (injected outside body-wrapper) */ .blog-cta { order: 10; } .blog-manifesto { order: 11; }