Property Investment News, Strategies, Tools and Opinions

Why Off-Market Properties Are Worth the Wait | Shrewdy

Written by Jake Milne | 12 Apr 2026, 11:00:00 pm

By Jake Milne, CEO & Lead Buyers Agent, MOGL | MOGL.com.au

Most buyers search the same two websites. Some houses sell without ever appearing on either. So who gets the phone call?

What "off-market" means

Off-market doesn't mean secret or dodgy. It means the house isn't on the big property sites yet. Maybe the seller wants a quiet sale. Maybe they don't want to pay for a full campaign. Maybe the agent is testing the price before it goes public.

For a buyer, that matters for one reason. Fewer people know about it, so fewer people are bidding against you. Less competition means more room to talk about price and terms.

But that raises the next question. If nobody can see these houses, how do you find one?

Who hears about them first

The agent calls the people they already know. That's the whole system.

I speak to selling agents across my target suburbs every week, whether or not a client needs something right then. When a listing lands on their desk before it goes online, I want to be one of the first calls they make. That call only happens if they know I have a real buyer who is ready with finance and can decide quickly.

You can do a version of this yourself. Pick two or three suburbs. Ring the active agents. Tell them exactly what you want and that your finance is approved. Then follow up, because one call won't do it.

The catch most people miss

Off-market is a way to get in early. It tells you nothing about whether the price is good.

Some sellers go off-market because they hope one keen buyer will pay more than an open campaign would get them. With no other bidders in the room, you also lose the easiest check on value. So the homework gets more important.

Before I'd offer on any off-market house, I'd run four checks:

  • Recent sales. What have similar houses nearby sold for in the last three months?
  • The reason. Why is the seller avoiding the open market? Ask the agent directly.
  • The building. Get a building and pest report, same as any purchase.
  • The walk-away price. Set it before you negotiate, and stick to it.

I miss more houses than I buy, mate. Most off-market calls I get end with a polite no, because the numbers don't hold up.

An off-market house is only a good deal if it would still be a good deal on the open market.

Want early access without doing the phone work?

If you'd like someone making those calls for you and checking the numbers on what comes back, book a free 15-minute discovery call. We'll talk through your brief and where you're at.

Book a free 15-minute discovery call

Jake Milne | CEO & Lead Buyers Agent, MOGL
MOGL.com.au | jake@mogl.com.au

This article is general in nature and does not constitute licensed real estate, financial or credit advice. Talk to your broker and accountant before locking anything in.