Sell or hold: the IRR test
One yearly percentage that sums up what a property has returned, to compare with what else your money could do.
IRR, internal rate of return, turns everything a property has cost and paid you into one yearly percentage. Compare it with what your money could earn elsewhere.
Worked example
| When | Cash |
|---|---|
| Purchase: deposit and costs | -$150,000 |
| Years 1 to 8: shortfall after tax | -$5,000 a year |
| End of year 8: sale, after the loan, selling costs and tax | +$310,000 |
IRR: about 7% a year.
How to use it
| Compare | Then |
|---|---|
| IRR if you sell now | With the IRR if you hold another five years on realistic numbers |
| Either | With your hurdle: the return you would want from this money elsewhere |
Your hurdle is personal. It depends on your goals, your alternatives and the risk you will accept.
What it leaves out
- How much work the property is
- Whether you can borrow again after selling
- Capital gains tax changes from 1 July 2027, which can shift the answer on when to sell
What MOGL does
The calculator at app.mogl.com.au works out the IRR for any property. On Premium you get a portfolio review at 12 months.
General information, not financial advice. Check the tax on a sale with your accountant.
Related: How capital gains tax is calculated · When to refinance or take out equity